Educated Earth // Videos - Making A Difference - Human Rights Throughout The World
User:
Pass:
Remember Me
Forgot Pass Register

Our educational work is entirely supported by people like you. Your donations directly add new exhibits and new features to the website, and even helps us open the Prehistoria Natural History Center!




eXTReMe Tracker

Videos / Making A Difference / Human Rights Throughout The World







Human Rights Throughout The World

Human Rights Throughout The World
The International Criminal Tribunal (founded after the genocide in Rwanda) is a signal that the world will no longer tolerate crimes such as genocide and nobody is immune from the law.


  • Currently 2.82/5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Rating: 2.8 / 5 (1041 votes)
Posted by nova on July 19, 2007
Hits: 4572

More Videos

Michio Kaku: Can We Resurrect the Dinosaurs?
Michio Kaku: Can We Resurrect the Dinosaurs?
Type: Biology & Medicine
The Mouldy Sloth
The Mouldy Sloth
Type: Life On Earth
Helping the World by Preserving Biodiversity
Helping the World by Preserving Biodiversity
Type: Making A Difference
Discussion: Richard Dawkins & Neil deGrasse Tyson
Discussion: Richard Dawkins & Neil deGrasse Tyson
Type: Astronomy
Gene manipulation
Gene manipulation
Type: Biology & Medicine
6 Ways Mushrooms Can Save The World
6 Ways Mushrooms Can Save The World
Type: Life On Earth
Machine Reverts Plastic To Oil
Machine Reverts Plastic To Oil
Type: Making A Difference
The Illusions Of Security
The Illusions Of Security
Type: Humanity
Genetic Modification In Humans - 3D Animation
Genetic Modification In Humans - 3D Animation
Type: Biology & Medicine
Mantis Eats Snake
Mantis Eats Snake
Type: Life on Earth
The Carina Nebula
The Carina Nebula
Type: Astronomy
How Algorithms Shape Our World
How Algorithms Shape Our World
Type: Humanity
Paper Dragon Illusion
Paper Dragon Illusion
Type: Miscellaneous
Bizarre Foods
Bizarre Foods
Type: Documentaries
Man VS Lion
Man VS Lion
Type: Life On Earth

Comments

Posted by John Q. Public on July 19, 2007 at 11:11 am
Do not misunderstand me... I am all for world peace and stopping genocide. However, there are problems with concepts such as International Criminal Tribunal. These are points to consider, and I am not convinced that they have been properly or thoroughly considered:

First: from whence to they derive their authority? The U.N.? But the U.N. is very strongly politically biased, and has other structural flaws. Do we (the U.S.) have international treaties authorizing the ICT to enforce their rules on, let's just say for example, ourselves? I highly doubt it. And that is not right, is it?

Second: Does whatever legitimate authority they possess (if any), trump the U.S. Constitution? Could the ICT try me for crimes in ways that are unconstitutional in my own country? If not, what about little countries with strange laws (like Sharia)? But if so, should it really be able to try U.S. citizens (and others) un-Constitutionally? Where does the double standard end?

Third (related to Second): If they are, or were, given authority that supersedes the Constitution, then what power keeps their own actions in check? What is to prevent them from punishing, say, political leaders for stuffing ballot boxes? One can say, "Yes, we really want those little democracies to be honest, so we should punish abusers. That is an International Crime." But if they went that far... they would have to put President Bush and friends in jail. (Probably some Democrats, too. I am not trying to single anyone out here, just making a point.)

So... once again, where does the double standard end? And what if the tribunal went even further with things that would henceforth be "prohibited"?

Who watches the watchers?

I could go on almost endlessly. Given the current world political climate, international bodies such as this -- when they are created as more than just temporary expedients in the face of atrocities -- are probably a Very Bad Idea. In the long run, they lead not to justice, but to moral and ethical morass. They make things more complicated and politicized, not simpler and more just.

The intent might be the best in the world, but history judges on results, not intent... and so far history does not have a lot of good to say about such organizations.

Be afraid. And stop giving your rights away to strangers. You might think it is doing good, but in the long run, it doesn't make the world a better place.
User: Pass: Remember Me

To comment on this item, please login or register.


Warning: Unknown: Your script possibly relies on a session side-effect which existed until PHP 4.2.3. Please be advised that the session extension does not consider global variables as a source of data, unless register_globals is enabled. You can disable this functionality and this warning by setting session.bug_compat_42 or session.bug_compat_warn to off, respectively in Unknown on line 0